The Thursday and Sunday games are final, and the panels need a chart review. Monday night’s Chargers-Ravens game hasn’t kicked off, so it isn’t graded here. I checked the picks pages for NFL.com’s five-editor panel and ESPN’s three-expert panel against the final scores.
Exhibit A: Packers, Five for Five, Wrong Five for Five
Every one of NFL.com’s five experts (Jeremy Bergman, Brooke Cersosimo, Gennaro Filice, Bobby Kownack and Dan Parr) picked Green Bay at home over Minnesota. Their scores had the Packers winning by one to six points. ESPN’s Pamela Maldonado and Eric Moody agreed. The Vikings won 30-10, a road win. Only ESPN’s Aaron Schatz took Minnesota, and he gets the lone gold star of the week.
Exhibit B: Eight Experts Walked Past Cleveland
All five NFL.com editors and all three ESPN experts picked the Texans at Cleveland. The Browns won 27-24 at home, per NBC Chicago, and DAZN’s scoreboard agrees. Nobody on either panel gave Cleveland a chance.
Exhibit C: Two Believers in New England
NFL.com’s Kownack (27-26) and ESPN’s Schatz (27-24) both picked the Patriots over the Lions in Munich. The other six panelists took Detroit. The Lions won 35-10, so the six were right and the two weren’t close.
A Clean Bill of Health
All eight panelists took the Bills over the Jets, and Buffalo won 31-12. All eight took Jacksonville over Tennessee, and the Jaguars won 40-23. All eight took the Colts over the Dolphins, and Indianapolis survived 24-22, which was closer than anyone drew it up. Seven of eight had the Chiefs over the Falcons, and Kansas City won 35-13 (Bergman was the lone Atlanta pick).
This Week’s Trend
The panels handled the lopsided favorites fine. They fell apart in games where their own predicted margins were a field goal or so. Two unanimous or near-unanimous calls, the Packers and the Texans, lost outright, and the Colts nearly joined them. When every expert on a panel agrees on a close game, treat it as a coin flip.

Leave a Reply