Updated Friday, September 25, 2026, ahead of Sunday’s Titans-Giants game.
Two weeks ago the Giants offense looked like a fantasy gold mine. Jaxson Dart went 23-of-29 for 230 yards and three touchdowns in the opener against Dallas, Isaiah Likely caught all eight of his targets, and Cam Skattebo ran for 81 yards and a score. Then Dart’s left knee gave out on the first drive in Los Angeles, and Jameis Winston threw for 111 yards the rest of the night. Dart is out for the regular season. This breakdown covers what that means for Winston, Malik Nabers, Likely, Skattebo, and Dart’s own dynasty value.
The Injury
Rams linebackers Josaiah Stewart and Byron Young sandwiched Dart as he jumped to throw on the opening drive Monday night. Tests showed damage to his MCL, PCL and meniscus. The ACL is intact, but the meniscus needs surgery, and NFL Network’s Mike Garafolo put that recovery at four to six months. John Harbaugh confirmed Wednesday that Dart is done for the regular season. He wouldn’t rule out a playoff return, and the Giants expect Dart to be ready for 2027. For the full medical breakdown, see The QB ICU.
What Changes for the Giants Offense
The Week 2 game plan was built for Dart, who ran 11 times for 54 yards in the opener, and Winston looked lost inside it. He completed 11 of 27 passes for 111 yards and an interception. NBC Sports had him 25 percent below his expected completion rate, the worst mark in the league that week. Harbaugh said the staff will build this week’s plan around what Winston does well, and offensive coordinator Matt Nagy has a few days to do it.
Expect two things from that plan. First, more running. Harbaugh’s Giants beat Dallas with long, clock-eating drives, and Winston’s interception habit gives them every reason to keep the ball on the ground. Second, the throws that do happen will be riskier. Winston has 156 touchdowns and 114 interceptions in his career. In his two Giants starts last season, against Green Bay and Detroit, he threw for 567 yards with two touchdowns and two picks. A passer like that raises the ceiling for the top target and lowers the floor for everyone else.
Protection is a question too. Left tackle Andrew Thomas (groin) missed Thursday’s practice after a limited session Wednesday. Harbaugh has also said the team will add another quarterback and won’t rule out a trade, so Winston’s hold on the job depends on how Sunday goes.
Player-by-Player Prescriptions
QB Jameis Winston
Superflex only. Winston is 3-9 in 12 starts since 2024 and hasn’t been a full-time starter since 2019. The schedule helps. New York’s next five opponents (Titans, Cardinals, Commanders, Saints and Texans) entered the week with a combined 2-8 record, and the Giants are 2.5-point favorites Sunday. That’s enough volume for usable superflex weeks. In one-QB leagues, leave him on waivers.
WR Malik Nabers
Start him as a WR2, and buy him if his manager is panicking. His Week 2 line was one catch for one yard, and his shoulder popped out during the game. He put it back in himself, returned, and said Thursday the X-ray came back clean. Winston has a long history of feeding his top receiver, and Nabers led the team with nine targets from Dart in the opener. His weekly range gets wider with Winston, but Nabers caught 109 passes for 1,204 yards as a rookie in 2024 with Daniel Jones, Tommy DeVito and Drew Lock throwing to him.
TE Isaiah Likely
Still a TE1, with a lower ceiling. Likely’s Week 1 (8-for-8, 78 yards, two touchdowns) grew out of a training-camp connection with Dart. Winston kept throwing to him anyway. Likely drew nine of Winston’s targets Monday, a 33 percent share, and led the team with 10 targets overall. He turned that into 8.3 PPR points, TE19 for the week. Target volume like that keeps him in lineups at a thin position, but expect fewer touchdowns.
RB Cam Skattebo
Low-end RB2, and the Giant I’d sell if someone offers fair value. A backup quarterback usually means more handoffs, but the Rams stacked the box once Dart left, and Skattebo managed 36 yards on 12 carries. He also shares the backfield with Devin Singletary and Tyrone Tracy, and Singletary took all four running-back targets in Week 1. With Winston, fewer drives reach the red zone, which cuts into Skattebo’s touchdown chances. He did catch all four of his targets for 19 yards Monday, which helps in PPR.
WR Darnell Mooney and the Rest
Deep leagues only. In Week 1, nobody besides Nabers and Likely topped four targets or 27 receiving yards. Winston has to prove he can support a third pass catcher before Mooney belongs on a standard roster.
QB Jaxson Dart
Drop him in redraft. In dynasty, hold him, or buy him if a manager wants to dump him cheap. He should be the Giants’ starter again in 2027. The risk is his injury file. Dart went through five concussion tests as a rookie, missed two games with a head injury, and had another concussion test this preseason before the knee.
Quick Chart
| Player | Before the Injury | Now | Prescription |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jameis Winston, QB | Backup | Starter after going 11-of-27 in relief | Superflex only |
| Malik Nabers, WR | Team target leader | WR2 with a wider weekly range | Start; buy low |
| Isaiah Likely, TE | Two Week 1 touchdowns with Dart | Low-end TE1 on target volume | Start |
| Cam Skattebo, RB | Lead back, 81 yards in Week 1 | Low-end RB2 facing stacked boxes | Flex; sell for fair value |
| Jaxson Dart, QB | Rising young starter | Out for the regular season | Drop in redraft; hold in dynasty |
Watch Nabers’ target count Sunday against Tennessee. If Winston gives him double-digit looks, his WR2 floor is safe. For every other injury on the Week 3 slate, check our Injury Report.

Leave a Reply